Did you hear that sound? That sound, right there? Okay, well, it's
either the sound of my heart forsaking Mead for all eternity, or there's
a murderer whose broken into your house and is SNEAKING UP BEHIND
YOU!!!!!
Look over your shoulder just to check that I'm wrong. You know you want to do it!
Storm Born, the tragic tale of a woman forced by cruel fate to be
hit on by ALL the men. Yes. That's what this story is about. Okay,
there are fairies and she has to recover some damsel in distress but
basically the novel is about Eugenie's love life.
I suppose my problem with Dark Born is that all of Mead's washed up,
tried and not-so-true tropes are here. Again. Strong heroine (who
will undoubtedly end the series as a complete moron), sexy hero who
heroine loves, though nobody really knows why. Secondary sexy love
interest who is way more awesome than sexy hero and who Mead spends far
more time fleshing out a real relationship with the heroine, but who is
apparently not the heroine's twue loff. For reasons completely unknown.
I will inevitably like this love interest far more than the banal and
boring love interest Mead champions.
The one thing I'll say about this novel is that Mead writes good
sex. That's her one redeeming virtue. She writes gripping, interesting
characters, a rich world and stories that hint at great possibilities,
but Mead absolutely sucks at the follow through.
The difference with this novel is that I'm not interested in
following through to watch her crash and burn yet another series. This
novel reminded me of a quote by Dan Hemmens from Ferretbrain.
"Rape is not the occupational hazard of having a vagina."
Thank you.
Now I'll address the fictional critics in my head by saying that
yes, Mead gave all these douches a reason to rape the protagonist that
wasn't just about sex. But... well, it just doesn't count and I'll
explain why.
I don't know about you, but *I* am personally sick of stories that
tell me that because I have a vagina, I am a walking talking victim
waiting to happen. Because novel after novel tells the same story. No
matter how strong, powerful or kickarse you are as a heroine, you are
still a victim and will need to be rescued by a man. Possibly several
times.
I'm sick to death of it. Barely a page goes by in this book where
rape isn't mentioned. Even if it's just to say, 'Eugenie, you're so
beautiful I'd rape you and LIKE it!"
This book almost treats rape like a fucking compliment. "I've had
five rape attempts today, what about you?" "Oh, I've had three." "Oh,
I'm so sorry to hear that. Don't worry, maybe tomorrow will pick up!"
I have a problem with drilling into people's heads that women are
victims. Always. Vulnerable, precious little petals. Don't let them
out of the house or they'll trip over their puritanical vaginas and get
raped. Or what about a message just as bad? Almost all men will rape
if given the chance. It's the rare few who won't take the opportunity
for a good ol' free for all on an unwilling woman.
Now hold on for an even bigger criticism. Of all the worst things, this was the WORST. POSSIBLE. THING!
This book... is like Anita Blake.
It's got multiple love interests, fairies, bargains made, political
sex, sexual awakening of formerly prudish, loner character, mystery,
evil women bitches out to get you. It's all so very reminiscent.
You know what? Don't read this book. Just go watch Generation 4 My
Little Pony instead. I promise there's no rape there and it's about a
thousand times better and more entertaining.
And there is no rape.
You really hit the nail on the head about Mead's tropes, and you described my feelings about her romances to a T There is something very seductive about her writing that compels me to keep reading even though I always end up hating myself for it afterwards.
ReplyDeleteThe rape culture that's being perpetuated in both Urban Fantasy and YA is getting a bit much. The sad thing is, it seems that writers tend to get much worse about it as time goes on. Anita Blake is the perfect example.
Thanks, Witchkitten. I agree, her books can be very moorish. They're like a soap opera - that's the closest I could compare them to. You know they're crap but you can't stop watching.
ReplyDeleteExcept now I've totally had enough of her.